Skip to Main Content

Scholarly vs. Popular Periodicals

Comparing Popular Magazines And Scholarly Journals

Periodical is a term given to items which are published on a regular basis, such as magazines, journals and newspapers. Periodicals come in a variety of styles, for a variety of audiences. They offer news, opinion, commentary, scholarly analysis, literary criticism, and reports of research, ranging from brief newsletters published by trade organizations to in-depth journals published by scientific societies and university presses. Magazines and newspapers may be appropriate for some research projects, but usually the most important sources for collect level research are scholarly journals.

Periodical Types & Examples Audience & Use Access Method & Examples

Newspaper

  • New York Times
  • Philadelphia Inquirer
  • Washington Post
  • Wall St. Journal
  • Current Information
  • News stories, features
  • Opinion and commentary
  • Texts of speeches, etc.
  • Includes a regional focus

Academic Search Complete

Newspaper Source

 

Magazines

  • Glamour
  • Jet
  • Men's Health
  • Psychology Today
  • Reader's Digest
  • Rolling Stone
  • Focused on the general public
  • Primarily for entertainment
  • Numerous ads, photos
  • Shorter articles/Broad overviews

Academic Search Complete

 

News Magazines

  • Economist
  • Maclean's
  • Newsweek
  • Time
  • Nontechnical language
  • Current events, overviews
  • Photographs, graphs
  • Book, movie reviews

Academic Search Complete

Masterfile Premier 

Opinion Magazines

  • Atlantic Monthly
  • Christian Century
  • New Republic
  • National Review
  • Educated audience
  • Particular viewpoint
  • Commentary on Politics and Society
  • Book, movie reviews, interviews

Academic Search Complete

Opposing Viewpoints In Context 

 

Trade Magazines

  • Advertising Age
  • Chief Executive
  • Community Banker
  • Restaurants & Institutions
  • Written for practitioners in specific occupations
  • Product information and ads
  • Current trends and practices
  • Meetings, jobs, personalities

Academic Search Complete

 

Scholarly Journals

  • Business and Society
  • Child Development
  • Journal of Alcohol Studies
  • Lancet
  • Nature
  • Science
  • Studies in Short Fiction

 

  • The technical language of the field
  • Often non-profit (no ads)
  • Charts, graphs, technical drawings
  • Reports of original research
  • Works cited, references
  • Research methods, results, discussions, literature reviews

Academic Search Complete

JSTOR

Psychology & Behavioral Sciences Collection

CINAHLwith Full Text